Have you ever wondered why people keep repeating the same thing in conversations over and over? If you’re anything like me, you can’t ignore the content of conversations because you know that language can be a window to the mind.
People repeat what they say for a number of reasons in a variety of contexts. I’m only concerned here with those instances where what they say over and over can provide clues to their psychological makeup.
First off, I want to be clear as to what specific instances I’m talking about. I’m not talking about instances where a person repeats something in a conversation because they feel they’ve not been heard- a person repeating their point in a debate, for example.
I’m also not talking about instances where it’s obvious why the person is repeating themselves. An example would be a child repeatedly asking for candy when her mother clearly has no intention of giving one.
The incidences I’m talking about are the ones where you notice that someone tells others the same thing that they’ve told you. It’s usually a story of an incident that happened to them.
Now my question is: Why would they, of all topics, keep saying the same thing to the people they encounter?
Before we delve into the possible reasons, I’d like to narrate an incident from my own life:
I and a few classmates were working on a group project in the last semester of my undergrad. We had two assessments for the project work- minor and major. During the minor assessment, our professor pointed out a shortcoming in our project work.
It’s natural to feel bad (no matter how slightly) when you experience something like this. But what I noticed was that not all of us in the group were affected in the same way by that remark.
While most of us forgot about it soon after, there was this one girl in our group who was clearly more affected by it than the rest of us. How do I know that?
Well, after that incident she kept repeating what the professor had said to almost everyone she talked to, at least in my presence. So much so that she even pointed it out in our major assessment despite my warning of not revealing anything that may undermine our assessment.
This intrigued and frustrated me. I confronted her and said, rather angrily, “Why do you keep mentioning it to everyone? Why is it such a big deal to you?”
She didn’t have an answer. She fell silent. Since then, I’ve noticed many people, including myself, engage in the exact same behaviour.
The mind is always trying to make sense of things
If someone tells you that your friend died in an accident and gives you a detailed description of what happened, you’re unlikely to ask any more questions. You may immediately slip into a state of shock, disbelief, or even sadness.
Consider what would happen if they only told that you that your friend died without telling you why or how. You’d desperately ask the same questions over and over till your mind makes sense of the incident (with the help of relevant answers).
This example is pretty straightforward where you’re repeatedly asking questions to get answers. But why would someone repeat something that is not necessarily a question?
Again, the answer is the same. Their mind is trying to make sense of what happened. The issue is unresolved in their mind. By repeating the same thing over and over, they want to resolve it and do away with it.
Many things that we encounter on a daily basis get easily resolved (I fell because I slipped, he laughed because I said something funny, etc.). But some things are not so easily resolved and leave deep impressions on us.
Consequently, our minds get stuck in this loop of trying to make sense of them because they haven’t made full sense to us yet.
Past traumas and repeating the same things
A person who has had a traumatic experience in the past may keep acting out these traumas in their dreams. Only by talking about the trauma repeatedly, trying to make sense of it, can they hope to end these dreams.
When we hear the word trauma we tend to think of some major unfortunate incident. But trauma also comes in other, minor forms. That remark our professor made was traumatic for the girl who went on to tell everyone about it.
When people get close to each other in relationships, they often talk about their bad past and childhood experiences. They may not overly express how those experiences traumatized them. They may try to portray the instances as entertaining or interesting. But the fact that they’re repeating these stories is a strong indication of trauma.
Next time your friend says, “Have I told you this before?” say “No” even if they have, just to get a better understanding of their psychology.
Justifying yourself and repeating the same things
Often, the bad experiences a person is trying to make sense of, by talking about them repeatedly, involve self-blame. On a deep level, the person thinks that they’re somehow responsible for what happened to them. Or at least, they had a part in it or could have avoided it somehow.
So when they are telling their story it’s likely that they’ll try to justify themselves. In doing so, they may even distort the story and narrate it in such a way that clears them of any blame and showcases them as victims.
Why do they do this?
We’re always trying to project a good image of ourselves to our fellow humans, especially those who matter to us. If there’s something in our recent or distant past that has the potential to degrade our image, we make sure that they know we’re not to blame.
This paradoxical situation of first blaming oneself and then trying to vindicate oneself usually happens on an unconscious level. So it’s no wonder that people keep repeating this behaviour without stopping to self-reflect.
It’s important to remember that these instances that people repeatedly talk about may not necessarily be traumatic. It could be anything they haven’t yet made full sense of.
When that girl in our project group repeated the professor’s remark, it didn’t traumatize me but it left an impression still. At the time, I wasn’t able to make sense of it.
Therefore, my mind kept replaying the incident over and over and I might as well have told the same story to others over and over but I didn’t.
Lucky for them, I’m often self-reflective enough not to engage in behaviours that may reveal my psychology. So I spared them the boredom. I’ve finally told the story and attempted to make sense of it via this article.
Hi, I’m Hanan Parvez (MBA, MA Psychology), founder and author of PsychMechanics. I’ve published one book and authored 300+ articles on this blog (started in 2014) that have garnered over 4 million views. PsychMechanics has been featured in Forbes, Business Insider, Reader’s Digest, and Entrepreneur. Feel free to contact me if you have a query.